Featured Experts

Maggie Koerth-Baker
Maggie Koerth-Baker is the science editor at She writes a monthly column for The New York Times Magazine and is the author of Before the Lights Go Out, a book about electricity, infrastructure, and the future of energy.
Next »
Henry Jacoby
Henry Jacoby is an emeritus professor at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Sloan School of Management, where he helps lead MIT’s research and analysis of national climate policies and the structure of the international climate regime.
Next »
The natural gas revolution and U.S. energy policy
Host Madeleine Brand and emeritus professor Henry Jacoby from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology discuss the impact that shale gas -- extracted by the method known as "fracking"-- has had on American energy policy.
SELECT field_seg_body_summary, delta FROM `field_data_field_seg_body` WHERE entity_id = 357 AND delta=0
  Previous  |  Next  

Henry Jacoby is an emeritus professor of Applied Economics at Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s (MIT) Sloane School of Management, and co-author of an MIT report called, “The Influence of Shale Gas on U.S. Energy and Environmental Policy.” 

Host Madeline Brand (MB): It seems like we are in the midst of a natural gas boom. When did that start and why is it happening now?

Henry Jacoby (HJ): It started out six or seven years ago and it’s happening because of the confluence of a set of technical developments that allowed the cracking up of gas that was in shale resources that are located at all around the country. That spread around very, very rapidly and it has led to a revolution in natural gas in the United States. 

MB: You’re talking about the advent of hydraulic fracturing or fracking?

HJ: That’s correct. It’s not just the fracking. It’s also the drilling technology that has changed this.

MB: I see. And, what has been the effect of this boom?

HJ: Well, if you go back six or seven years, there was essentially no gas out of the shale into the United States’ economy, and, as of now, it’s about a third of the total United States’ gas supply, which is just a dramatic change. If you go back six or seven years, people were building lots of facilities to import gas into the United States because everybody expected the price of natural gas to rise over time and be high enough to pay for importing gas. Now, all those facilities are sitting empty. So, it has been a huge change.

MB: That’s amazing in such a short period of time.  Have you ever seen anything like that before?

HJ:  I have been around the business for a while and it is shocking how fast this took place. The sheer scale of the changes in unprecedented.

MB: So that’s dropped the price of natural gas?

HJ:  It has. Of course, natural gas prices have been volatile – up and down and up and down – but in terms of what people expected the price to be, it has definitely dropped the price of natural gas.

MB: Natural gas has been touted as a clean energy alternative to traditional petroleum products. What do you think? Do you think it is clean energy? Do you think that it needs to be looked at more carefully in terms of its environmental impact?

HJ: Well gas isn’t really a substitute for oil. Gas is a substitute for coal. Gas is a much cleaner technology than coal, used mainly in electric power, both in terms of what you think of is normal pollutants in urban areas and also in terms of greenhouse gas emission. So yes, it is cleaner.

MB: It’s cleaner for the environment?

HJ: All these technologies have their environmental cost in the production and so there are issues in the production of this gas, just like there are in the production of all other energy sources we use.

MB: Right. There has been a lot of controversy in terms of its effect on ground water, streams and rivers.

HJ: Yes.

MB: So we have this boom in natural gas and what is that doing to other forms of renewable energy? Is it tamping down the interest in creating the other forms of energy because there is so much natural gas?

HJ: Yes. I think it does have the effect of lowering the expectations of the growth of opportunities in renewables. A lot of the renewables that are being done now, solar, wind and such, are being driven mainly by subsidies and by various types of regulations, mandates, and the like, but the potential for investment in these technologies – if you go back some years – was stimulated a lot by the expectation that natural gas prices are going to be rising over time. Now, it looks like they won’t be for quite some time and that makes it less likely that these technologies are going to become competitive without subsidies and regulations in the major use for them which is in electric power generation.

MB: Right because it’s just more expensive to use the other form of energy than natural gas?

HJ: That’s right. They are more expensive than natural gas at the prices we have now. Yes.

MB: What are you talking about? Solar? Wind?  

HJ: I’m talking about solar and wind.

MB: So, is this the end of coal?

HJ: No, it’s not the end of coal so long as we have no penalty on greenhouse gas emissions from power plants. We’ll continue to use coal until have we some real concern about CO2.

It also is the case that even though United States' use of coal has gone down over time, because the cost difference is so great now with these lower gas prices. These gas prices aren’t going stay at this level for long periods of years and as the gas price gradually crawls back up to a more competitive level without all of this excess overhanging the market, then some of that coal will come back in the U.S. system. So, it’s not the end of coal in the absence of a climate policy. 

MB: So, where do you see the United States in ten, 15, 20 years in terms of its energy makeup? 

HJ: I think gas will continue to play a big role in the electric power system more than it’s played in the last 20 or 30 years. 

MB: Even though there has been this incredible push for renewables and the prices have dropped precipitously over the past few years? 

HJ: Yes, because even though the prices have dropped, the renewables are not necessarily economically competitive against other sources, mainly of electric power. So, the prices have dropped and they are growing rapidly, but the problem is they start from such a very low scale -- wind and solar is only like two to three percent of the total production of the country -- so even if you have a rapid rate of growth, which we do, it doesn’t displace the rest of the system in that short of period of time.

  Previous  |  Next  

Global Energy and Innovations / Produced by Jocelyn Ford, Curt Nickish, Bianca Vazquez Toness and A.C. Valdez / Edited by Martha Little with additional production help from Flawn Williams / Web Producer: Philippa Levenberg / Photos via Flickr: pjmixer; djwtwo and AP photos: Bettmann/Corbis and Ajit Solanki.

Host: Madeline Brand/ Length: 51 minutes / Airdate: April 2013

This show was made possible through the generous support of Qatar Foundation International and the Stuart Family Foundation.

Click here to read a report on this show by our Ombudsman, Jeffrey Dvorkin, in response to the Fairness and Accuracy in Reporting article published May 31, 2013.

blog comments powered by Disqus



America Abroad is an award-winning documentary radio program distributed by Public Radio International (PRI) and broadcast on public radio stations nationwide. Each month, we take an in-depth look at one critical issue in international affairs and U.S. foreign policy.

Anchored by public radio host Madeleine Brand, this monthly program covers global issues ranging from the challenges in Iran and North Korea, to the European debt crisis and the roots of the Arab Spring.

The hour-long broadcast combines original reporting, expert analysis, and historical pieces that incorporate archival audio and eyewitness accounts. No other public radio program devotes the same amount of time, depth of coverage, and level of analysis to a single issue in international affairs.

America Abroad is broadcast on more than 100 public radio stations around the United States. For full programs, check out the links below.

Copyright 2013 America Abroad Media | 1701 Pennsylvania Ave, NW Suite 300 Washington, DC 20006        Contact Us | Site Map | Privacy Policy